Musing

Jan. 22nd, 2003 09:44 pm
[personal profile] blodeuedd
News came out a few days back about the forthcoming Harry Potter book; I can just see the stampede of addicted youths clamoring for their fix come June.

I must admit I'm of two minds about the phenomenon. On one hand, I can understand how a story such as that one would fire people's imaginations, especially for kids who through it discover the joy of reading (now, to nudge copies of "The Golden Compass" into their unsuspecting hands...) but on the other, they're not that great. Good, but not great. They're fun to read, sure, but I can't recall any of them giving me shivers of real feeling and not a single tear wet the pages of the copies I read. Perhaps it's just me, but I don't find that they generate much emotion, just action. The fourth one was much better in this respect, but it may be only that the protagonists have hit puberty and internal conflicts are arising.

I feel like starting an ongoing thread about the books I've read and loved, but I think I'll start with the perhaps less-known ones. So tonight, I bring you "The Neverending Story".

What stayed with me from this book are ghostly images, surreal like a Leonor Fini painting and shifting. A disembodied voice wailing through ruined columns; two snakes in an endless ring; two sphinx (sphinxes?) facing each other in a desert of endless night; a lion running over many-coloured sand dunes, always at the edge of my vision; an ivory tower, as far away as it is high; a young boy and an old man laying pieces of illustrated glass on the snow and going back down the shaft for more. There was a woman with red hair, a dragon with a voice like a great bronze bell and the Nothing, the terrifying void eating away at reality.

Date: 2003-01-22 07:42 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] arya.livejournal.com
All of the Harry Potter books have made me cry. I'm sure that most HP readers think the Dursleys' abuse, and the longing for parents he will never see, are exaggerated. They aren't. Losing a parent forever, and being reviled and mistreated by the other, Harry's longing for his mom & dad, and his courageous tolerance of the Dursleys, those are all things that I know about. That's why I love the HP books. Not because Harry is the greatest wizard ever. But because it's an escapism, makes me wish that I'd had a Hogwarts to run away to when my father became unbearable.

Re:

Date: 2003-01-23 05:10 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] blodeuedd.livejournal.com
It's not that I find that exaggerated, because I know some people do go through that, it's that the writing didn't allow me to connect enough with Harry to feel it as the pain of someone I knew, as opposed to someone I'd just read about. The scene where Harry stumbles upon the mirror of Erised in the movie made me choke up, but I can't remember feeling that way when I read it. The fourth book, however, felt much more real to me in terms of emotions. If the series continues in that vein, I think I'll end up rating it much higher than I did after finishing the third book.

I also wanted to tell you that you seem like a very cool person. Hang in there! *hugs*

Profile

blodeuedd

February 2012

S M T W T F S
   1 234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
26272829   

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jan. 2nd, 2026 11:15 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios